Chapter 3: Writer, Editor, Man about Town


 Flatiron Building, New York City, 1906
Arthur entered the business world in August 1905, as a writer and editor for Physical Culture Publishing Company, located in the newly constructed Flatiron Building in New York City.  We presume that Maude and Arthur, Jr. did not join him because he rented an apartment in Washington Square’s Benedick building, which leased exclusively to bachelors.

Their marriage must have been in serious trouble by this time, and Maude and son had long since returned home to Washington to live with her parents.  To date, we are unable to locate either wedding or divorce records.  The only evidence for the marriage is newspaper articles and the birth records of Arthur, Jr.  We surmise that Arthur and Maude separated soon after his return from Australia in the late summer of 1905, and they probably finalized their divorce settlement by 1910.

Maude would remarry in 1913.  Their only child was named Robert Holt Featherstone, Jr.  Interestingly, that would make Maude the mother of two sets of “Juniors.”  In 1921 she divorced Mr. Featherstone, and for a time, both of Maude’s sons lived with her parents in Washington.  By 1931 the boys and Maude were living in her deceased parents home.  She never married again but continued living in D.C. until her death in 1947.  Arthur, Jr. grew up living most of his life in Washington too.  (In 1960 when I first attended Georgetown, Arthur, Jr. was living in the college area as a clerk for the FAA and later the US Post Office.)

-------------

By 1907 Arthur had left New York and returned to Boston alone, having joined his mother and sisters in their Roxbury tenement.  He soon accepted a position with the Boston Post newspaper as a sports writer.  This allowed him to better support his mother, who for years wished to get away from tenement living.  In late 1908, Catherine got her wish and purchased a new home in Newton, one of Boston’s suburbs some five miles to the west.

Although Arthur was now the main breadwinner, three of his unmarried sisters also continued to support the household.  They worked in downtown Boston at a dry goods store located down the street from the Boston Common: Mary was a bookkeeper, Catherine C, an auditor, and 18-year-old Elise was an entry clerk.  The girls may have commuted to work with Arthur, who worked only a few blocks away.  The fourth sister, Julia, had married in 1908 to a John Murphy and they moved ten miles west to Needham.


16 Marlboro Street, Newton (July 2011)
Between 1911 and 1914, three more Duffey children left to get married, leaving only Mary.  The Newton home was slowly becoming vacant.  In 1914, Mother Catherine began contributing financially to the family home enterprise by renting out a room to a boarder, Eugene De Allesser Thore, a Boston ink salesman. His office was also down town not far from the where the girls worked. Meanwhile, oldest daughter Mary stayed on and served as her mother’s caregiver until Catherine’s death in 1922.  Within a few months, 50-year-old Mary wedded 47-year-old Eugene.  They continued to live in Catherine’s home, which they now owned.  Following Eugene’s death in 1929, Mary supported herself by renting out four rooms in the house, where she remained for the rest of her life.
1912 Illustration from "For Old Donchester"

While living in the family home, Arthur wrote two novels aimed at high school boys:  On the Cinder Path, (1911) and, For Old Donchester (1912).  Both of these stories focused on the traits necessary to be a successful student athlete.

For Old Donchester was a fictional story seemingly set at his own Worcester Academy.  The narrative follows the track career of one of the students, Archie Hartley.  It suggests that a good athlete must also exhibit a balance between physical, mental and moral excellence.  The book is well written, interesting, and generally very upbeat.  However, it is apparent that it was created in a different era, as much of the language seems rather archaic when read today, not unlike his earlier narratives.

During this time, Arthur met a lady, Helen Louise Daley, of the Boston suburb, Neponset.  Helen’s parents, John and Mary, were born in Ireland, married in Boston, and raised seven children.  Her father John worked as a carpenter until his death in 1898 at age 54.  Like Arthur’s mother, Helen’s mother received support from her children.

Of her siblings, Helen achieved the highest grade level, completing the tenth grade.  None of the others got beyond eighth grade.  Helen and her two younger sisters worked as stenographers while her brothers went into the woodworking business.

Washington Times, 23 Feb 1911 and St Ann Church, Neponset
Helen was still living at home when she and Arthur met.  It is tempting to speculate that she worked as a stenographer in downtown Boston, possibly not too far from Arthur’s workplace at the Boston Post, and that's where they met.  In any case, they married on 22 February 1911.  Marriage records indicated it was Arthur’s first. However, the wedding ceremony took place in St Ann's Parochial Residence rather than inside the church. Perhaps Arthur had been unsuccessful in gaining a papal annulment for his marriage to Maude and was therefore not allowed to receive the sacrament. Despite this, the Duffey family remained strong Catholics, who attended mass weekly.

106 Dakota Street, Dorchester
September 2014
Arthur and Helen rented their first house in Dorchester at 106 Dakota Street.  Built in 1905, the home was about three miles south of where Arthur was born and about two miles north of where Helen was born.

In April 1912, they had their first child, Arthur (Archie) Francis, Jr.  It is rather amazing that there were now two Duffey sons with the same name: Arthur, Jr. (1904) and Arthur, Jr. (1912).  In February 1914 my father, John (Jack), was born.  Both boys were born at the nearby Dorchester Cottage Hospital, a small facility with capacity for twelve patients run entirely by nurses.

Boston Post on Washington Street, 1944
Arthur had begun a long and successful career with the Boston Post.  Once the largest newspaper in Boston and one of the largest in the country, the Post had a circulation of well over a million readers at its height in the 1930s.  It also engaged in intense competition with the other publications located along downtown Washington Street’s "Newspaper Row" including the Boston Journal, the Boston Globe, the Boston Herald, the Associated Press, and the Boston Evening Transcript.

Newspaper Row, 1927
During major events, Washington Street would fill with spectators awaiting election results, the outcome of baseball games, or the latest reports of battles fought abroad.  It was this crowd that awaited Arthur’s picks for the upcoming 1912 Olympic games.  And among his favorite track-and-field athletes was an up-and-comer named Jim Thorpe.

Kenna Record (NM), 29 Aug 1913
The Post also allowed Arthur to voice his passionate views about amateur athletics.  He felt it hypocritical that AAU officials could enjoy monetary rewards from sports equipment companies.  Was it not a conflict of interest?  Meanwhile, Arthur’s offense was signing a contract to write for Physical Culture magazine.  In 1914, Arthur wrote, “If well known athletes are to be prevented from writing for newspapers or magazines on account of their athletic affiliations, why doesn’t such a rule equally apply to some the rulers of the game who receive emolument from such sources simply because of the
Washington Times, 29 Apr 1914
athletic affiliations?”


In April of 1914, Arthur found time to take on a part-time secondary job as track coach at Tufts College (now Tufts University) in suburban Medford.  He also continued his involvement with Georgetown, using his influence with the Boston Athletic Association to arrange track meets in 1911 and 1912 between Georgetown, Holy Cross and Boston College.  He served as a substitute coach while his old friend, Georgetown’s Coach Foley, attended to other members of the team at another event in Baltimore.

Please click to enlarge

1st Lieut A.F. Duffey
World War I started in 1914.  The U.S. declared war on Germany on 6 April 1917, following the German U-Boat sinking of the Lusitania off Ireland.  But it wasn’t until the summer of 1918 that the War Department requested Arthur’s services.
Training soldiers to relay, 1918

Prior to the war, nations took physical education less seriously as they began to rely more heavily on machines in battle.  However, the war quickly showed that physical education was a top-tier need in all aspects of the military.  Arthur had just turned 39 in July 1918, too old be sent into battle.  However, the US Sanitary Corps (precursor to the US Medical Services Corps) appointed him to be a physical director of training in Long Island at Camp Mills, where Army Air Service pilots prepped for overseas deployments.  Arthur specialized in improving pilots’ reaction time and endurance. Once trained, the pilots would then disembark from camp and be transported to the Port of New York to receive their ship assignments to France. Arthur entered the service as a first lieutenant, but he could not have served very long, because the war ended on 11 November 1918.


74 Orvis Road, Arlington; September 2014
He resumed his career with the Boston Post.  In short order the family continued its growth.  By 1916 the family had moved yet again to Tonawanda Street, a mere six-minute walk from their Dakota Street home.   Daughter Helen arrived in November 1918, at Dorchester Cottage Hospital, just as her older brothers had.  

Even the latest Duffey home was getting a bit too crowded, so Arthur and Helen decided they could now afford to buy a new place.  By late summer 1919, they purchased their first-and-only home at 74 Orvis Road in suburban Arlington.  Built in 1916, the eight bedroom house featured a darkly painted wood exterior and a second floor porch.  Arthur's youngest sister, Elise, had married an undertaker in 1913 and lived just down the street.

The Duffeys soon reached full strength with the birth of son, Bill, in December 1919, and Roger in January 1922.

Coach Duffey at Northeastern University, 1921 (click to enlarge)
Meanwhile, Arthur had also returned to track part-time as a coaching assistant at Boston’s Northeastern University during their 1920-21 season.  The following year he volunteered to become the first head coach of their fledgling baseball team.  Although the team lost the majority of its games, they still considered it a successful entrance into inter-collegiate baseball.

In the arena of amateur athletics, September 1921 brought a little encouraging news when the New England Registration Committee of the AAU recommended that Arthur’s 9 3/5 seconds record for the 100-yard dash from 1902 be restored to the official books.  But the recommendation did not hold up and his record ultimately remained stricken.

This was not long after the time when Arthur became friends with Charles Paddock, Olympian, world record 100 meter sprinter, and fellow newspaperman.  Charley revealed the connection between Arthur’s refusal to wear Spalding shoes and Sullivan’s displeasure.

James Michael Curley (1874-1958)
Among Arthur’s other influential friends includes the colorful character, James Curley, a Boston politician popular particularly with Irish Americans.  He served four non-consecutive terms as Boston’s mayor, twice in the US House of Representatives, and once as Governor of Massachusetts.  His endearment among Irish Americans began as a result of an incident when he and a friend took civil service exams for two men in his district so that they could get federal government jobs.  Constituents saw him as fighting for the little guy and enjoyed his public-works contributions such as hospitals, parks, roads and bridges.  The funding may have been corrupt, but he achieved results.

Mayor Curley shared a somewhat similar background with Arthur.  Both grew up in Roxbury tenements, lost their fathers at a young age, and were known for their genial personalities.  Most importantly, they enjoyed each other’s company.  They often spent time together at the mayor’s second home at Nantasket Beach.

Herbert Warren Wind, a friend of the mayor’s children, wrote about his childhood encounter with Arthur in the mid-1920s.  The article appeared in Sports Illustrated in December 1958:

Practice  Practice  Practice
I do not know for a fact but I have an idea that part of the mayor's addiction to track and field was the result of his friendship with Arthur Duffey, then a sportswriter for the Boston Post.  He was a fairly frequent visitor to Nantasket, and he had something of the mayor's elicitive friendliness.  During one chat with him I remember feeling on such confidential terms that I told him I was a fairly fast runner but was slow off the mark and wondered what I could do to improve this.  "I will tell you," he said, and in such a way that I felt he was going to divulge some secret, like shutting your eyes or sucking in your breath, that only a world's record holder could know.  "The secret," Mr. Duffey went on, "is to practice starts.  Get out there and practice, practice, practice."  You should never talk to children that way.  They are not ready for the facts of life.

Ogden Standard Examiner, 15 June 1926 (with earlier photos for comparison)

The Duffey family was the subject of a short magazine article, appearing in the December 1927 issue of Popular Science.  A photo captured the family (minus mother Helen) jogging on Orvis Road, in front of their home.  At about this time, the taller, 15-year-old Arthur, Jr. would be able to out-sprint his dad.  In 1933 he would equal his dad’s high school 100-yard record with a 10.0 second sprint while attending Philips Exeter Academy in New Hampshire.


The year 1929 provided a bit of controversy in the running world with the introduction of a device intended to expedite races and maintain the integrity of cinder tracks: portable, adjustable starting blocks.  Prior to their use, athletes took time before each race to dig holes for their feet several inches below the track.  Older runners like Charley Paddock initially dismissed the blocks as a mechanical aid, and Arthur likened the blocks to a springboard that would give runners an unfair starting advantage.  Ironically, the face of the new Nicholson Starting Blocks was none other than 17-year-old Arthur, Jr. (aka Archie).  Newspapers across the country featured Archie demonstrating their use.  By the end of the year, the controversy had waned and most critics agreed that the blocks offered no real advantage to a runner's speed.


---------------
As Post head sports editor, Arthur established the tradition of predicting winners of important sprints and the annual Boston Marathon.  Below is a segment of one such Boston Post article, 7 July 1928 Olympic Track Trials held at Harvard Stadium:

DUFFEY PICKED WYCKOFF TO WIN!
Coast Wonder Runs True to Form in "Sprint of the Century" and Fulfills Expert's Prediction

BY ARTHUR DUFFEY

Great sprinting races there have been in the past.  Great sprinting contests there will continue to be in the future.  I doubt very much if we will ever see any finer sprinting displayed than that in the 100-metre run in the final Olympic tryouts in the Harvard Stadium yesterday afternoon.

I know not what the Olympic 100-metre dash over in Amsterdam this summer is going to have to offer.  But one thing appears certain and that is it will not be a harder fought, a more thrilling or a race that will call for more speed and stamina than that same sprint within Harvard's classic Stadium yesterday.  Heralded as the "Sprint of the Century" it proved to be in every respect.  When Charley Paddock, the "Fastest Human," Frank Lombardi, and last but no means least, Frank Wykoff of the Glendale High School, were billed to meet in the sprints at the Los Angeles Stadium in the far Western tryouts recently (6-16-28), it was labeled as the greatest sprint of all times.  But it was a misnomer.  Yesterday's 100-metre run in ‘the Stadium’ was the finest piece of sprinting displayed in the history of American sprint running.

Frank Wykoff, that wonderful high school phenom of California came through a winner as I predicted.  I had no misgivings about this wonderful runner going to prove himself a champion of champions when once I saw him in action.  I did not select Wykoff on any hearsay, or without the deepest respect for his competitors.  They all ran brilliantly.  But there was only one Wykoff in the race, and I might add once in a lifetime.  When the writer recently visited California he had a chance to become acquainted with the wonderful sprinting prowess of this Glendale High School runner. You could talk about the Paddock’s, Borah’s, Lombardi’s and the hundred and one other sprinters, but there was only one Wykoff and that is how it happened yesterday.

------------

On the family side of the things, the Duffeys were living very comfortable lives in their Arlington neighborhood.  In 1940, Arthur’s annual salary at the Post was $3120.  That was a good salary then and was the highest in the neighborhood.  In the 1930s and 40s, they would also rent out parts of their home for additional income.  Their house was valued at $4500 in 1940, down from $14,000 just prior to the Depression.  In 2015, the house was estimated to be worth $801,915.

Harvard varsity lacrosse 1936
A lot was certainly going on in the Duffey family: the two older boys, Archie and Jack, had graduated from Arlington High School, went on to Phillips Exeter Academy in New Hampshire, and ultimately Harvard University in 1936.  At Exeter, Archie equaled his dad’s 100-yard ‘schoolboy’ record of 10.0 seconds. He was certainly the most gifted athlete of the boys. Jack focused more on the books and excelled in his studies; he even skipped fifth grade.  This placed both boys in the same grade level although Archie was nearly two years older.  Their relationship became strained, creating a new rivalry and ultimately resentment by Archie.  The two were never very close after that.  Each had his own group of friends and interests.

Archie, Jack,
Bill, and Roger
Perhaps as a result, Jack and the younger Bill became the closer brothers.  Like his older brothers, Bill attended his first two years of high school in Arlington.  Then, like his father, he went on to Worcester Academy, graduating in 1940.  Bill quickly became a standout among the Hilltoppers, involving himself in social clubs and lacrosse.  He served as co-captain of the hockey team as well as a senior class officer.  Sister Helen finished high school and became a stenographer like her mother.  The youngest brother, Roger, prepared for Harvard (1945) at Arlington High.  He would pursue a newspaper career like his father.

But there was another element lurking just below the surface.  Arthur had developed an issue with alcohol over the years, perhaps not too surprising as he continually socialize with Boston's elite. My father (Jack) and Archie’s relationship became further strained as a result of Arthur’s drinking. The issue must have been a challenge for the whole family. During the 1930s when Arthur’s two oldest boys, Archie and Jack, were in high school/college, it reached a peak.  Many a late evening, the Duffey household would receive a call from the police or a Boston tavern owner demanding someone retrieve their father.  My dad usually won the honors.  He did not understand why, and it did not sit well with him because he thought Archie, as the oldest son, should have inherited the opportunity.  This matter continued to be an embarrassment to the family.

Then World War II broke out.  By 1942 the household was missing most of the kids, except for Roger, who was a member of ROTC while attending Harvard.  The older boys, Archie, Jack, and Bill, had joined the service and headed for various theaters of war, and daughter, Helen, was about to be married. 

One Father’s Day during WW-II, probably 1944 or '45, the headline article on the Boston Post’s sports page featured a drawing of the Duffey sons in uniform with their famous father, sketched by the Post’s Bob Coyne (1898-1976).


In 1949, Arthur retired from the Post after 41 years of sports writing and editing.  As people began to receive news bulletins from radio, there was no longer need to wait on Washington Street for the latest headlines.  During the 1940s the Post was in serious readership decline and would eventually go out of business in October 1956.
------------

Following WW-II, Capt Jack Duffey's family lived in the Boston area (Lexington), sharing a home with his best friend Phil Lane, his wife (sister of my mother), and their son.  I can still remember my dad instructing my brother and me how to perform the famous "Duffey Crouch Start."  Other kids were interested too. Occasionally we visited with my grandparents, Arthur and Helen Duffey.

In the summer of 1948, Dad received an assignment to Greenville Air Force Base, so our family set off to South Carolina.  But within a year we returned to Boston because my father, then USAF Lt Col Jack Duffey, was suddenly reassigned to Naha, Okinawa in early 1949.  Arthur helped my mother and us two boys find a new rental home.  My mother, Louise, was most appreciative of his support.  At the time, Bob and I (Jack, Jr.) were in first and second grade respectively.  Mom would take us to visit the Duffey grandparents' home on Sunday mornings after mass.

Everything seemed old.  The two-story house was dark brown and somewhat past prime. There were always Boston Post and Globe newspapers around the home, especially on the floor.  I especially remember their large, circa 1920s RCA Victrola Record Player, with its 78-rpm vinyl records.  It was something else.  We had to wind it up with a large hand crank on the right side to get it to run, and then it only seemed to run for several minutes, just long enough to play one record. The records featured marching bands from the 1920s and 30s.  Bob and I liked to go into the room and play the magnificent machine.  It was located in its own, dark, heavily draped room.  It too seemed like a cave to us.

Arthur & Helen Duffey, 1950
We rarely saw Arthur (Bumpa to us kids) get up from his couch in all our visits. He was 71 years old in 1950 but seemed even older.  He was a little difficult to understand too.  Before we returned home, he would always “remove his teeth” for us. Wow, was that something to behold!  He also insisted on offering us fish bone sandwiches, “My favorite,” he said.  We always declined but were in fear that one day he would give us one.  These were never easy visits for us boys.

We would view some of his running medals in one of the darkened rooms.  At the time, I had no idea that he had been a famous athlete.  One afternoon we all went out on their upstairs porch and Mom took this photo of Bumpa and Grammy.  It would be hard to associate this Arthur with the sprinter of 1902.  This was the last time we would ever see Grammy or Bumpa.

In 1953 our family was now living in the Washington D.C. area.  One evening we received a call from Orvis Road that Helen had just passed away.  It was one of the few times I ever saw my father in tears.  I can still recall the intriguing cut-out map book (one country per page) that Grammy gave me on Christmas 1949.  How could she have known me so well?  I was grateful for that special gift, which would spur my life-long interest in geography.
   
Two years later another call came that Arthur had died of a fatal heart attack while at Boston’s Deaconess Hospital.  The date was 23 January 1955; he was 75 years old.  Following a high mass at St Agnes Catholic Church of Arlington, he was buried at the Mt Pleasant Cemetery alongside his wife, Helen, in plot Z-250. 
As the only sibling still living in the Boston area, Arthur's only daughter, Helen Shea, handled the estate matters. Unfortunately, high expense required her to sell off many of Arthur and Helen's possessions.  But she  managed to keep a few medals in the family to remind Arthur's descendants about his achievements.  Thankfully none of his track medals were ever confiscated in the black days of 1905-06.



Washington Times, 18 October 1903 (click to enlarge)

About 55 years after his death and over 110 years since his track career ended, Arthur’s legacy took a turn for the better.  Due in part to the efforts of one of his grandsons, Bill, Jr., Arthur’s accomplishments were honored at the USA Track and Field Hall of Fame induction held in Daytona Beach, Florida in December 2012.

Four of Arthur's grandchildren brave the Blizzard of 2015
On January 25, 2015 he received a second hall of fame induction.  This one was from the Massachusetts State Track Coaches Association Track and Field Hall of Fame. Again, Bill served as catalyst in garnering this award for our grandfather.  At the ceremony, Arthur was honored for his brilliant sprinting record while attending Worcester Academy and Georgetown.  Four of Arthur’s grandkids attended. We all remarked at the time, “Better late than never!”  I believe Arthur must have been feeling pleased and very proud about what he was viewing that morning.

Arthur’s campaign to illuminate the amateur-professional athlete issue of the early 1900s had paved the way for finally getting it right.

No comments:

Post a Comment